Nestled along the Great South Bay, Oakdale is a charming neighborhood known for its historic estates, tree-lined streets, and welcoming, close-knit community. Picturesque waterfront views and a blend of classic Victorian homes and cozy cottages give Oakdale its timeless appeal, making it a serene haven with a rich sense of local pride.
Oakdale presents a calm and peaceful environment with low traffic noise contributing to its tranquil ambiance. The housing primarily consists of single detached homes alongside some duplexes and small apartment buildings, offering a variety of three or four-bedroom options built mostly since the early 1970s. Residents benefit from convenient access to primary schools and a selection of nearby supermarkets, restaurants, and cafes. Transportation includes multiple bus lines and rail service on the Montauk Branch, while parking remains plentiful. The mild terrain supports cycling as a practical option for getting around, enhancing connectivity throughout the community.
The character of Oakdale is exemplified by its slower-paced atmosphere. Oakdale is very good for those who like quiet surroundings, as there isn't a lot of street noise or city clamor.
Parks, schools, dining, and what makes this neighborhood special
Situated along the Connetquot River, the historic Idle Hour estate is the former home of William K. Vanderbilt, now recognized for its striking architecture and scenic grounds. Although Dowling College is closed, the mansion remains a notable Oakdale landmark with rich history and stunning waterfront views.
A sprawling 3,400-acre nature preserve in Oakdale, renowned for its tranquil walking trails, horseback riding, birdwatching, and fly fishing on the picturesque Connetquot River. It's a treasured local destination for outdoor enthusiasts and families looking to enjoy Long Island's natural beauty.
Located on Montauk Highway, Coyle’s is a beloved family-owned ice cream parlor famous for its homemade flavors, retro vibe, and classic sundaes, making it a sweet staple for Oakdale residents and visitors during the warm months.
Set on the banks of the Connetquot River, Oakdale Yacht Marina attracts boating enthusiasts with its slips, boat services, and waterside restaurant, offering a hub for the local boating community right in the heart of Oakdale.
This historic Long Island Rail Road stop on Montauk Highway has been serving Oakdale since the 19th century, offering convenient commuter access and a touch of old-world charm with its classic station house and proximity to neighborhood shops and dining.
Things to do, events, and what's happening this month
A weekly farmers market right in Oakdale, offering fresh local produce and community atmosphere—ideal for residents looking to shop local and enjoy a Saturday morning outdoors.
View event details →A creative parent‑child painting event at nearby Islip Library where caregivers and kids collaborate—a perfect local outing for Oakdale families with young children.
View event details →A hands‑on sewing workshop for adults at the local library—great for Oakdale residents wanting to build creative or practical skills in a community setting.
View event details →A women‑focused fishing expo just minutes from Oakdale offering fly‑fishing clinics, river tours, and knot‑tying—excellent for community members interested in outdoor recreation and learning new aquatic skills.
View event details →A themed girls’ night at a local Oakdale restaurant—great for adults looking for a fun, social evening close to home.
View event details →Outdoor morning beach yoga and horseback trail rides near Islip offer residents healthy, scenic activities to start the weekend.
View event details →Stories, updates, and things to know in Oakdale
Local characteristics and demographics for Oakdale
